By Edward Shulman (487 words)
Posted in DAPA/DACA on February 16, 2016

There are (0) comments.

The future of the United States Supreme Court, and an estimated four million immigrants affected by its upcoming decision on DAPA, lies in the balance due to the death of Justice Antonin Scalia, the former leader of the court’s dominant conservative contingency.  There is no way for Scalia's seat to be filled before the DAPA hearing (United States v. Texas), which is scheduled to commence in April.  Thus, Justice Scalia’s death leaves the court with two basic options in dealing with the Immigration Executive Order case, if the justices are deadlocked at 4 to 4, regarding whether to allow DAPA to proceed. One is an automatic affirmation of the lower court decision, which would terminate the possibility of DAPA. The other is to set the case aside for re-argument in the term that starts in October in the hope that it will be decided by a full court, which would provide better odds that DAPA would be approved.

Should President Obama be allowed to exercise his constitutional responsibility in nominating a successor and select a Democratic candidate with a pro-immigration stance, then the chances of DAPA being passed would be extremely high.  The problem is that many Republicans in Congress are vowing to reject any nominees set forth for consideration by Obama in a political game-playing effort to stall an appointment of a Democratic appointee. Senate Majority Leader, Mitch McConnell, although the husband of an immigrant, has a history of voting against immigration reform and opposing DAPA, vocalized his strong opposition to filling Scalia's vacancy during Obama's term. 

There are two other interesting pieces to the puzzle of whether or not DAPA will be passed. Although the court’s Democratic appointees are expected to back DAPA, it has been hypothesized that Justice Sotomayor may possibly recuse herself from the case for having strong ties to some of the groups championing DAPA.  The other wrinkle in the DAPA case is Justice Anthony Kennedy, whose opinion about DAPA and his potential ruling for or against DAPA is currently unclear.

There is no doubt that Justice Scalia's passing will affect DAPA.  New Jersey Immigration Attorney Edward Shulman is on the pulse of newsworthy events impacting DAPA. Please continue to visit the Shulman Law Group website for up-to-date information regarding DAPA and other immigration-related topics.  Likewise, if you, a colleague, friend, neighbor, or family member may qualify for DAPA benefits, please schedule a consultation to determine DAPA eligibility and begin the process of documentation accumulation and preparation.  Indeed, should DAPA be passed, we would like our clients to be at the front of the line in terms of receiving DAPA benefits with the upmost expediency.

Comments (0)

no comments posted

Leave a comment

* denotes required field
* Email will not be published
* Used to help prevent spam

Text only, html will be removed from comment

To make the long story short - I wouldn't be here now writing this review if it wasn't for him. He fought with me and for me as if he was defending himself and not some stranger from a foreign country. I will highly recommend him - if your case has any chance at all he is the one you need.

-Immigration Client

Breaking News


In response to President Trump's disbanding of the DACA program, two Republican Senators, James Lankford of Oklahoma and Tom Tillis of North Carolina, unveiled a proposed bill this week which is being touted as a "conservative" approach to protecting...

read more


New York Attorney General, Eric Schneiderman, along with 15 other Attorneys General from around the country and the District of Columbia formally filed a lawsuit against the Trump Administration yesterday due to the termination of the DACA program. ...

read more


Yesterday, the Trump administration formally announced the end to DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals), a program that has protected from deportation an estimated 800,000 young documented immigrations brought to the United States as...

read more
© 2015 The Shulman Law Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Website Design by Hudson